My 09 had one of the defective front tires, you know the one that was mounted backwards due to being marked wrong. Mine wore out with a little over 6000 miles on it. I didn't know it was defective, never got a notice from Harley. Anyway Brother-in Law informed me of defective tires on 09's so I took it to the dealer and they checked it. Yes it's defective but it is worn down more than 3/32 of an inch in one or more places so all they can allow is 1/2 the cost of a new tire. Now does that make sense. The tire was defective and that's what caused it to wear so fast. They said if I had brought it in before it had worn more than 3/32 of an inch they would have covered the full cost of the tire. I had no Idea the tire was defective(was not informed by Harley) I was trying to get as many miles as I could out of it! That's the kind of things that tick's me off!