Meziere-Reverser-web-ad-90x750-r3 copy

150 Most Recent Posts

Thread AuthorPostersPost AuthorForumThread/Post Link
Papa Zook239ol' schoolNew Member Introduct...What Made You Join TrikeTalk Forum?
PKLGW2pawsHonda Trikes2007 gl1800 motor trike
ultrafxr5Papa ZookHarley Tri GlideFinished at last . . . well at leas...
Noodles1072NotgrownupHarley Freewheeler /...Very Nice Gloves
ultrafxr5NotgrownupHarley Tri GlideFinished at last . . . well at leas...
Papa Zook239rhino 2New Member Introduct...What Made You Join TrikeTalk Forum?
PKLGW2PKLGWHonda Trikes2007 gl1800 motor trike
Papa Zook239skisnow806New Member Introduct...What Made You Join TrikeTalk Forum?
Speedy Pete12JTJerseyNew Member Introduct...New member from Alberta, Canada
Just BOB2Just BOBStallion Trikesinfo
ultrafxr5Longbeard71Harley Tri GlideFinished at last . . . well at leas...
ultrafxr5ultrafxrHarley Tri GlideFinished at last . . . well at leas...
ultrafxr5TrampasHarley Tri GlideFinished at last . . . well at leas...
ultrafxr5ultrafxrHarley Tri GlideFinished at last . . . well at leas...
Noodles1072Noodles107Harley Freewheeler /...Very Nice Gloves
Speedy Pete12cycle7447New Member Introduct...New member from Alberta, Canada
RISal24!12cycle7447New Member Introduct...New member..new to trikes
phillipschuckann6Papa ZookHonda TrikesWho made my trike?
RISal24!12ol' schoolNew Member Introduct...New member..new to trikes
Bama boy4Grey_Ghost_27Stallion TrikesStallion fuel pump
phillipschuckann6trike ladyHonda TrikesWho made my trike?
RISal24!12trike ladyNew Member Introduct...New member..new to trikes
Speedy Pete12RustyBNew Member Introduct...New member from Alberta, Canada
RISal24!12Marc HNew Member Introduct...New member..new to trikes
Bowie11RustyBNew Member Introduct...New to trike, old time rider
RISal24!12RustyBNew Member Introduct...New member..new to trikes
RISal24!12rhino 2New Member Introduct...New member..new to trikes
RISal24!12hardwickbvNew Member Introduct...New member..new to trikes
Bowie11hardwickbvNew Member Introduct...New to trike, old time rider
RISal24!12Uncle FesterNew Member Introduct...New member..new to trikes
Bowie11ZammyNew Member Introduct...New to trike, old time rider
RISal24!12SullyNew Member Introduct...New member..new to trikes
RISal24!12ZammyNew Member Introduct...New member..new to trikes
Chief80138520fdHarley Tri GlideHow many miles on your Triglide?
RISal24!12GorillaNew Member Introduct...New member..new to trikes
RISal24!12RISal24!New Member Introduct...New member..new to trikes
woody19woodyHonda Trikes2019 Goldwing CSC
DK Custom Products362NotgrownupHarley Tri GlideWhat did you do to Your Tri-Glide T...
Bouncer10NotgrownupHarley Tri GlideDrive Belt Replacement Time
Bouncer10BouncerHarley Tri GlideDrive Belt Replacement Time
Bouncer10BouncerHarley Tri GlideDrive Belt Replacement Time
phillipschuckann6GorillaHonda TrikesWho made my trike?
rjd637brianlHonda Trikes1989 Honda Goldwing trike opinions
DeathBySnuSnu19GorillaVW Powered TrikesVolkswagen Kit Cars
DK Custom Products362520fdHarley Tri GlideWhat did you do to Your Tri-Glide T...
SHARKDIVER4DK Custom ProductsGeneral Harley Chatsuper shox
phillipschuckann6trike ladyHonda TrikesWho made my trike?
phillipschuckann6ol' schoolHonda TrikesWho made my trike?
phillipschuckann6rhino 2Honda TrikesWho made my trike?
phillipschuckann6phillipschuckannHonda TrikesWho made my trike?
Bowie11Uncle FesterNew Member Introduct...New to trike, old time rider
RedOregon12RedOregonHarley Tri GlideUpgrades on '24 Triglide?
DeathBySnuSnu19DeathBySnuSnuVW Powered TrikesVolkswagen Kit Cars
Bowie11woodyNew Member Introduct...New to trike, old time rider
Just BOB2GorillaStallion Trikesinfo
SHARKDIVER4WindyOneGeneral Harley Chatsuper shox
Bouncer10GorillaHarley Tri GlideDrive Belt Replacement Time
Just BOB2Just BOBStallion Trikesinfo
Chief80138CagmoHarley Tri GlideHow many miles on your Triglide?
PopPop13consitterNew Member Introduct...New Member
TxHarleyRider2Papa ZookHarley Trike Convers...Need help bad with conversion.
PopPop13Pegasus1300New Member Introduct...New Member
Bouncer10NotgrownupHarley Tri GlideDrive Belt Replacement Time
PopPop13ol' schoolNew Member Introduct...New Member
Bowie11ol' schoolNew Member Introduct...New to trike, old time rider
Chief80138DOKKHarley Tri GlideHow many miles on your Triglide?
Bouncer10BouncerHarley Tri GlideDrive Belt Replacement Time
Bowie11trike ladyNew Member Introduct...New to trike, old time rider
Bowie11GorillaNew Member Introduct...New to trike, old time rider
Bowie11rhino 2New Member Introduct...New to trike, old time rider
Bowie11Marc HNew Member Introduct...New to trike, old time rider
SaltBushBill11Marc HNew Member Introduct...New member
Bowie11BowieNew Member Introduct...New to trike, old time rider
Rick Sinacore9RawhidekenHarley Tri GlideTour pack reinforcement
SaltBushBill11Uncle FesterNew Member Introduct...New member
Burnerboy3tommyv333Harley Trike Convers...Hey Bozo (Andrew)
Old Aviator5Old AviatorHonda TrikesGreasing a Motortrike Coupe SA rear...
Old Aviator5Old AviatorHonda TrikesGreasing a Motortrike Coupe SA rear...
Noodles1073JTJerseyHarley Freewheeler /...Tobacco Fade
Noodles1073trike ladyHarley Freewheeler /...Tobacco Fade
Old Aviator5Phu CatHonda TrikesGreasing a Motortrike Coupe SA rear...
SaltBushBill11SullyNew Member Introduct...New member
ronc44242Papa ZookHarley Tri Glidequestion
TxHarleyRider2TxHarleyRiderHarley Trike Convers...Need help bad with conversion.
Chappy KC5StrelnikovFrankensteinFrankenstein Kit
jerry1@iw.net4StrelnikovFrankensteinFrankenstein owners
TxHarleyRider2Papa ZookHarley Trike Convers...Need help bad with conversion.
Skavoola14SkavoolaNew Member Introduct...New to Trike Talk
Old Aviator5GoldWingrGregHonda TrikesGreasing a Motortrike Coupe SA rear...
El Lobo10El LoboHarley Tri GlideBeen away for a while
SaltBushBill11GorillaNew Member Introduct...New member
cissywalton2GorillaCalifornia Sidecar T...how do I change out the reverse bel...
Noodles1073Noodles107Harley Freewheeler /...Tobacco Fade
Old Aviator5Old AviatorHonda TrikesGreasing a Motortrike Coupe SA rear...
SaltBushBill11trike ladyNew Member Introduct...New member
ronc44242ronc4424Harley Tri Glidequestion
Old Aviator5SkavoolaHonda TrikesGreasing a Motortrike Coupe SA rear...
Old Aviator5rhino 2Honda TrikesGreasing a Motortrike Coupe SA rear...
Old Aviator5Old AviatorHonda TrikesGreasing a Motortrike Coupe SA rear...
cissywalton2cissywaltonCalifornia Sidecar T...how do I change out the reverse bel...
Skavoola14PosseRiderNew Member Introduct...New to Trike Talk
Skavoola14woodyNew Member Introduct...New to Trike Talk
PopPop13woodyNew Member Introduct...New Member
Speedy Pete12woodyNew Member Introduct...New member from Alberta, Canada
Vulcanology10woodyNew Member Introduct...New member
SaltBushBill11woodyNew Member Introduct...New member
SaltBushBill11hardwickbvNew Member Introduct...New member
Vulcanology10hardwickbvNew Member Introduct...New member
Speedy Pete12hardwickbvNew Member Introduct...New member from Alberta, Canada
SaltBushBill11rhino 2New Member Introduct...New member
RedOregon12NotgrownupHarley Tri GlideUpgrades on '24 Triglide?
SaltBushBill11ol' schoolNew Member Introduct...New member
Vulcanology10ol' schoolNew Member Introduct...New member
Speedy Pete12ol' schoolNew Member Introduct...New member from Alberta, Canada
D'07ShadowAero6ol' schoolNew Member Introduct...My Older and Dear Friends Gideon! M...
SaltBushBill11scuzziNew Member Introduct...New member
SaltBushBill11SaltBushBillNew Member Introduct...New member
PopPop2Pegasus1300Can Am Spyder Trike...New Member
Vulcanology10GorillaNew Member Introduct...New member
Vulcanology10rhino 2New Member Introduct...New member
Speedy Pete12Marc HNew Member Introduct...New member from Alberta, Canada
Vulcanology10Marc HNew Member Introduct...New member
TxHarleyRider2TxHarleyRiderHarley Trike Convers...Need help bad with conversion.
Speedy Pete12trike ladyNew Member Introduct...New member from Alberta, Canada
rjd637trike ladyHonda Trikes1989 Honda Goldwing trike opinions
DrCrazyTrain13Uncle FesterNew Member Introduct...Introduction
Vulcanology10Uncle FesterNew Member Introduct...New member
Speedy Pete12Uncle FesterNew Member Introduct...New member from Alberta, Canada
Speedy Pete12rhino 2New Member Introduct...New member from Alberta, Canada
Vulcanology10ZammyNew Member Introduct...New member
Speedy Pete12ZammyNew Member Introduct...New member from Alberta, Canada
RedOregon12RKplus10Harley Tri GlideUpgrades on '24 Triglide?
RedOregon12RedOregonHarley Tri GlideUpgrades on '24 Triglide?
SHARKDIVER4DK Custom ProductsGeneral Harley Chatsuper shox
RedOregon12DK Custom ProductsHarley Tri GlideUpgrades on '24 Triglide?
DanTheMan1DanTheManNew Member Introduct...Where Have All The Good Trikes Gone...
RedOregon12ultrafxrHarley Tri GlideUpgrades on '24 Triglide?
RedOregon12David792Harley Tri GlideUpgrades on '24 Triglide?
Rawhideken121dn5upHarley Tri Glide2024 Tri glide
rjd637pawsHonda Trikes1989 Honda Goldwing trike opinions
RedOregon12RedOregonHarley Tri GlideUpgrades on '24 Triglide?
Speedy Pete12Speedy PeteNew Member Introduct...New member from Alberta, Canada
Rawhideken12PosseRiderHarley Tri Glide2024 Tri glide
rjd637GorillaHonda Trikes1989 Honda Goldwing trike opinions
Vulcanology10GorillaNew Member Introduct...New member
Dragon3W3JNPStallion TrikesStallion Heater Fan Motor
rjd637trike ladyHonda Trikes1989 Honda Goldwing trike opinions
Vulcanology10trike ladyNew Member Introduct...New member
Vulcanology10VulcanologyNew Member Introduct...New member
Burnerboy3BurnerboyHarley Trike Convers...Hey Bozo (Andrew)
Likes Likes:  2
Thanks Thanks:  0
Results 1 to 7 of 7

Thread: Alternate Frame?

  1. #1
    40+ Posts Shadow Dreamer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2016
    Location
    Roscommon, MI USA
    Posts
    45
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

    Default Alternate Frame?

    I'm playing with an idea in my head and was wondering what others think...See, I know I'm not the greatest welder in the world, but I can do a bang up job with fiberglass. So, with that in mind, I'm toying with the idea of using carbon fiber weave and epoxy resin to build my frame. What do YOU think?

  2. #2
    VW Tech Expert Loner's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Location
    Harvest, AL USA
    Posts
    431
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

    Default

    I for one appreciate the attributes of the carbon fiber weave and similar materials. I worked with military designers and test labs for years coming up with all types of components for missiles and other applications. I also owned NovaTrikes and did stress analyses and tests on frame designs. The biggest stress area(s) on a trike (or most any motorcycle) are in the tubes supporting the neck. These primary stress points are a few inches from the neck itself, both on the backbone and the downtubes. Stresses in these areas could easily reach 8-10 thousand pounds laterally.

    DOM tubing .125" thickness and 1.250" OD is rated exceeding 63,000 pounds stress. With those numbers in consideration, I would strongly question whether the high strength weaves could stand those dynamic stresses. Perhaps if machine-rolled carbon fiber thread over a tubing shaped mandrel with continuous resin flow (that's how high-burst rocket engine containers were made, but even then that was burst strength, not lateral stress.

    If you know the technical attributes of carbon fiber and feel like a nominal size tube can handle high lateral stress then you may can manufacture something that works.

    My numbers are somewhat simplified and summarized (you don't want to see a true stress analysis - it can make one's eyes cross), bit my advice would be to use a good heavy DOM for your frame and use your composites skills for body-work and other components.



  3. #3
    40+ Posts Shadow Dreamer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2016
    Location
    Roscommon, MI USA
    Posts
    45
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Loner View Post
    I for one appreciate the attributes of the carbon fiber weave and similar materials. I worked with military designers and test labs for years coming up with all types of components for missiles and other applications.
    That's actually where I got the idea in the first place. While I was in the Army, I serviced the AH-64A and got to work with the guys in the "body shop" on the airfield. Since then, in civilian life, I've had multiple opportunities to apply that same technology. That led me to the thought that it has to be possible. I know that a group of Swedish college kids built a carbon fiber bike, but that was a crotch rocket and used a unibody approach.

    Quote Originally Posted by Loner
    DOM tubing .125" thickness and 1.250" OD is rated exceeding 63,000 pounds stress. With those numbers in consideration, I would strongly question whether the high strength weaves could stand those dynamic stresses. Perhaps if machine-rolled carbon fiber thread over a tubing shaped mandrel with continuous resin flow (that's how high-burst rocket engine containers were made, but even then that was burst strength, not lateral stress.
    Well...I talked with one manufacturer of carbon fiber weave and epoxy. The attached pic is a screen shot of the stress test information he had available. The problem is that it is ONLY for 10 ply, flat test pieces, cured at room temp (no autoclave or vacuum). He's specifically asked the engineering group (I only got to talk to a salesman) but they haven't done any testing on tubular uses, even though they sell a tubular weave (think Chinese finger cuffs...that's how their weave is). Click image for larger version. 

Name:	Stress.jpg 
Views:	202 
Size:	202.0 KB 
ID:	37617

    Quote Originally Posted by Loner
    If you know the technical attributes of carbon fiber and feel like a nominal size tube can handle high lateral stress then you may can manufacture something that works.

    My numbers are somewhat simplified and summarized (you don't want to see a true stress analysis - it can make one's eyes cross), bit my advice would be to use a good heavy DOM for your frame and use your composites skills for body-work and other components.
    Thank you for the input Loner. I'm a touch shy of going through with it yet, due to the "unknown" stresses involved and the fact that CF has awesome strength in one direction, but can be absolutely lousy in a different direction.
    ~SD

  4. #4
    750+ Posts
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    east windsor ct
    Posts
    792
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

    Default

    just a thought....
    why not get your frame tacked together and have a pro welder finish welding it

  5. #5
    40+ Posts Shadow Dreamer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2016
    Location
    Roscommon, MI USA
    Posts
    45
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by stacebg View Post
    just a thought....
    why not get your frame tacked together and have a pro welder finish welding it
    Cost mostly....my area is mostly tourist based consumerism. There aren't any real industrial places here, which translates to having to make at least an hour drive to find a welder I would trust enough to do a better job than I could. That's not to say there aren't any welders close by, but they're all stick-jockeys who taught themselves how to weld their trailers back together after flipping their boat on the way home from a drunk fest on one of the lakes. Of course, there's the option of buying a MIG welder, but the cost for gas in my area is prohibitive, and I'd have to make that same hour drive to pick it up.

    I also like the idea of the weight to thrust ratio. Since I'm using a Fiero as my donor, the Iron Duke (2.5l) only produced 92 hp, stock. 1.25" x 0.125 DOM steel has a weight to length ratio of approximately 1.45lbs/ft. vs. 0.143lbs/ft. for commercially produced tubing (meaning hand laying my own would probably be closer to 0.3-0.4 lbs/ft if I'm realistic about it). When considering just the main rails, 2 pieces of 10-12' pipe or tubing, the weight difference is dramatic:

    DOM steel pipe: 14.5 - 17.4 lbs per pipe or 29 - 34.8 lbs for both
    CF tubing: 1.43 - 4.8 lbs per tube or 2.86 - 9.6 lbs for both

    Depending on whom you ask, those main rails account for anywhere from 1/4 to 1/3 of the entire weight of the frame (not including engine mounting), which takes the weight of the trike up to somewhere around 104 - 139.2 lbs for the steel frame, but you're still around 8.58 - 38.4 lbs for the CF.

    The Fiero had a curb weight of 2462 lbs, or just over 1 American ton. IF I can get that weight down to 1% of the "original" weight, that SHOULD increase my MPG from the stock Fiero's 21MPG up to close to, if not over, 40 MPG (approximate adjustments for wind resistance calculated in), where sticking with the steel frame, IF I did my math right (which I am almost always right when it comes to math) I'll only see around 29-32 MPG.

    Since I am forced to live on the limited budget (married family father of 4 kids) disability affords me, I have to think more than twice about every penny spent. That extra 8-11+ MPG will actually go a long way for me when you consider the price of gas. Yesterday had to fill up our only vehicle at a price of $2.35/gal.

    That's why I'm interested in seeing if there's a safe way to do it with carbon fiber, stacebg

  6. #6
    850+ Posts vwbug72501's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2015
    Location
    Batesville, AR. 72501
    Posts
    714
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

    Default

    I'm by NO means an expert on the subject, but it sounds like you are trying to approach your CF frame using metal tube designs. How about a monocoque chassis approach? I would think that CF lends itself better to that approach. There might be some good information on chassis design on the Society of Automotive Engineers Student Competitions sites.

  7. #7
    40+ Posts Shadow Dreamer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2016
    Location
    Roscommon, MI USA
    Posts
    45
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by vwbug72501 View Post
    I'm by NO means an expert on the subject, but it sounds like you are trying to approach your CF frame using metal tube designs. How about a monocoque chassis approach? I would think that CF lends itself better to that approach. There might be some good information on chassis design on the Society of Automotive Engineers Student Competitions sites.
    I know a group of university students in Sweden made a uni-body-ish motorcycle (after reading THEIR article again and taking a much closer look at their build), and it seems as though they used a modified monocoque chassis. I had considered that, but to be honest, I'm a little scared that my design might not work doing it that way.

    Now, I've got...looks like 20 tabs open and am researching it through the avenue you suggested, vwbug. THANK YOU! This is sparking all kinds of new ideas, just seeing how others have approached a similar issue. I'm on my 5th article/paper about race car frames, and I'm beginning to think I may want to keep my focus on their designs, issues and ideas, since the end effect isn't to build something that I can turn into a production model, but rather turn into a custom, one-off machine that will give me the performance I'm hoping for. Again, thank you for directing my attention....sometimes I get stuck on an idea and can't see the forest for the trees.
    ~sd

Similar Threads

  1. v8 frame? ???
    By ratrodney in forum Home Built Trikes
    Replies: 7
    Last Post: 04-22-2016, 11:00 PM
  2. Vw frame
    By vwbuild in forum New Member Introductions
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 12-16-2014, 02:58 AM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •