Actually, I was in the same situation…. I also have an extra set of stock wheels.
I am in process of custom painting my 2014 Tri Glide a HOK (House of Kolor) Kandy Brandywine and wanted to also powder coat to match, but determined it would not match 100% and would look more like a “mistake”.
So, I ended up having them Powder Coated “Super Chrome”. It still does not look exactly like chrome, but is very nice!
I’ve already made a decision (for next year) to send out my other set for a 100% chrome plated set.
but getting back to your original question… yes, I’ve seen many Colors that the powder coater can do, but be prepared that it will not be a perfect match.
(pics attached of the front wheel … I just got a new tire and will be mounting it this weekend)…. Matching Rears are still in boxes and will be getting new tires for the rear next month):
View attachment 116882View attachment 116883View attachment 116884