I have had both, I have the velour now, I had it for 5 or 6 years, love it. but like any thing on a bike you need to take care of it, keep it clean, cover for it when it rains, ( it not a big deal if it does get wet, just dry with a towel as much as you can and it will completely dry quickly ) or mine does. not as hot in the summer and not as cold in the winter.